Blockchain technology is all about decentralization and virtualization. So it’s a little ironic that humans love to come together in person at big blockchain events. Such was the case last week in Seoul, where a record 17,000 people and 300 speakers came together for Korea Blockchain Week.
Like traditional tech conferences, the event featured a lot of big names in the field, both the high-profile (Vitalik Buterin, Richard Teng of Binance, and Mark Karpeles among them) and the no-profile (researchers, professors, and many founders of new startups).
Unlike normal confabs, you also got the ha-profile: apes, penguins, ducks, and bears were also on the list.
No one would ever accuse the crypto world of lacking merry pranksters. But all the same, there remained a strong undercurrent of unease in the crowd. Mainstream adoption appears to have stalled, and with the U.S. elections coming up, there is a big question mark over what regulation will look like going forward.
We walked the halls of the event, and chatted with lots of attendees. Here are some of our impressions:
Historically, scalability has been a major issue for blockchains with high fees and slow transaction speeds. Now, second-layer blockchains (so-called “layer-2 blockchains”) have made transactions both faster and cheaper, meaning scalability is no longer an issue for most use cases. The most popular layer-2 blockchains can handle millions of transactions per day without any hiccup.
But despite that, usage isn’t necessarily picking up, in part because we remain in a kind of application vacuum.
“I think the expectations for real application content have significantly increased,” said Simon Kim, CEO of Hashed, a venture capital firm focusing on blockchain and crypto. Speaking to TechCrunch, Simon highlighted a need for more practical use cases.
There are some glimmers of that starting to emerge, specifically in the world of IP content tracking. Last month, Story raised $80 million to build a blockchain to help IP owners track usage of their content more effectively. And Sony Block Solutions Labs, a joint venture formed by Sony and Startale Labs, unveiled its new public blockchain network, Soneium, that promises to make it easier for users to protect creators’ rights and share profits fairly.
“These are the industry’s first attempts at creating a content-focused IP ecosystem,” Simon said.
Others at the show said they were looking for more real-world applications that consumers could grasp.
“For the past six years, we’ve developed various infrastructure — roads and highways — in the crypto world. Now, we need to focus on things people enjoy or use such as convenience stores, clothing stores, and department stores,” according to Steve Lee, co-founder of Neoclassic Capital, a Miami-based crypto investment firm backed by venture capitalists Marc Andreessen, Chris Dixon, and Tampa Bay Lightning owner Jeff Vinik.
The firm, as it happens, focuses on applications in consumer and financial services. “From a consumer perspective, we are particularly bullish on use cases in gaming IP, entertainment, and social applications,” he said.
Neoclassic launched its first fund in April, and the firm aims to pursue more investment opportunities in these sectors. “While the West may continue to lead in infrastructure development, we view Asia as having greater potential for these [web3 consumer use cases] compared to the West,” he said, citing the high volume of bitcoin trading in the region and its track record in areas like gaming and entertainment. Countries like Japan and Korea, he said, “have been leaders in adopting new technologies faster than any other country in the world.”
While some crypto companies are still looking for breakthrough successes, others are trying to convince traditional enterprises that they should add a crypto twist to their existing products.
Justin Kim, head of Asia at Ava Labs, a blockchain platform focused on decentralized apps (“dApps”) and enterprise blockchain deployments, noted that more organizations are launching their own custom blockchains on top of Avalanche.
“The list includes California DMV, Konami Digital Entertainment, Nexon MapleStory Universe, OtherWorld’s Solo Leveling animation, and financial institutions such as JP Morgan and Citi,” he said.
Tokenizing new asset classes is also a recent trend, Justin added. For example, Republic, a New York-based investment platform, is tokenizing funds to support film financing. IT consulting firm Questry and Japanese bank Mizuho Securities are tokenizing a fund to support animated content production. Justin noted that both projects are based on the Avalanche platform.
Stablecoins are also making their way into mainstream financial and messaging apps.
One notable development has been PayPal introducing a stablecoin called PYUSD and other messaging apps like Japanese Line and Telegram integrating crypto wallets. Naver, a part-owner of Line, also recently launched a crypto wallet within its payment app in Korea. “Stablecoin] trading activity is picking up,” Simon said.
Hashed collaborates with other traditional companies such as Korean entertainment company HYBE, Japan-headquartered gaming company Nexon, financial institutions KB Kookmin Bank in South Korea, and Siam Commercial Bank in Thailand, Simon said.
Another area that’s drawing attention from the industry, he pointed out, is the gaming space. The gaming industry is one of the fastest-growing sectors, particularly with the increase in online transactions, Simon added.
“So there’s content, and then the AAA games are going to start pouring out of the market later this year,” Simon said. In the past, blockchain-based games with experimental tokens or NFT ownership were released while still in the experimental phase. “Now, well-made, high-quality games are coming out.”
Yat Siu, co-founder and executive chairman of Animoca Brands, a Hong Kong-based game and software company that also operates a web3 VC firm, disagreed, saying that gaming projects, which have basically been launch pads for tokens, so far haven’t done that well.
“People are not excited about [gaming] right now, but I think we will come back,” Siu said.
In the same way, NFTs are not grabbing people’s attention at the moment, but boosters still have hope.
“Back in the early days, when people didn’t see the internet as interesting or real, they just kept building it, and eventually it just grew, right? That’s pretty much how I see the [NFT] space as well,” Siu added.
In 2023, lower- and middle-income countries were driving cryptocurrency adoption; this year, adoption is spread more evenly between richer and poorer countries, said Diederik van Wersch, regional director of ASEAN and Hong Kong at blockchain data platform Chainalysis.
“The mainstream adoption of cryptocurrency could be a result of the launch of Bitcoin ETFs, which triggered an increase in the total value of Bitcoin activity across all regions,” van Wersch told TechCrunch.
In keeping with that, institutions are facilitating the adoption of cryptocurrency in nations such as Singapore and Indonesia, he said. The U.S. followed a similar pattern. When the U.S introduced a Bitcoin ETF, Siu said it was a step change for the market.
“Tokens that have institutional backing tend to do better. That’s how things are shaping up for crypto moving forward,” Siu said.
“In Singapore, we’re seeing a rise in the use of crypto merchant services, while in Indonesia, crypto is being used as a trading instrument and has become one of the fastest-growing crypto markets in the region with the highest year-over-year growth at nearly 200%,” van Wersch said.
That’s not all good news: As more people adopt it, there will likely be more crime, he added. “As adoption grows, so will crime. And today, crypto is encompassing all types of crime — including fraud and narcotics.”
The arrest of Telegram founder Pavel Durov in France last month definitely led to an aftershock for the Telegram-linked Toncoin, which slumped in price in the wake of the news. But by the time KBW rolled around just a week later, the mood was buoyant.
Rushi Manche, co-founder of Movement Labs, told TechCrunch that Telegram had become a useful communication tool for many in the crypto community, and that was not likely to change in the short term.
“What happened to Pavel Durov and what’s happening with Telegram and TON is proof that decentralization is working quite well. Despite the fact that Pavel was arrested, everything was still working,” Siu told TechCrunch. “I would say it’s a net positive and, to me, shows the resilience and strength of decentralization and the benefits of running something on the blockchain. So I’m long-term bullish on TON and Telegram.”
Animoca Brands is an investor in TON, the blockchain that is deeply integrated into the messaging app.
Simon acknowledged one takeaway from the incident: It highlighted how new regulations need to be created to manage these virtual spaces independently, because there are no physical borders in the digital world and states can’t control what’s on the internet.
Regulation time and again came up as the biggest concern among people we spoke to at KBW, and not just among those working in Asian crypto, but those from other regions, too.
“Until a few years ago, many blockchain builders had established their headquarters in Singapore,” Simon said. “Most recently, the UAE has emerged as the most industry-friendly country, providing clear regulations and guidelines within the nation.”
Regulations — and specifically the clear establishment of light regulation — have shaped where development has thrived.
“The main concern we hear is the need for regulatory clarity across different Asian jurisdictions,” said Manche of Movement Labs. “However, this is driving a push for more coherent, innovation-friendly policies. Regulatory clarity should improve globally, potentially accelerating institutional adoption. We also foresee a focus on sustainable blockchain solutions and innovative token economics.”
A lot of it has been piecemeal, however. Japan was the first mover in this space, and Singapore started early, too, with a light-touch regime focused on anti-money laundering (AML) and countering the financing of terrorism (CFT), according to Chengyi Ong, head of policy for the APAC region at Chainalysis. Then Hong Kong and India followed suit with their own regulatory framework. “And that’s how we ended up with a regulatory patchwork,” she said.
The U.S. election in November could be a moment when some of this finally comes to a head in that country. “Depending on who wins, this industry will accelerate faster. But I think crypto will grow in America regardless,” Siu said. “This is not an endorsement, by the way.”
Keep reading the article on Tech Crunch
Lawyers representing Sam Bankman-Fried, the FTX CEO and co-founder who was convicted of fraud and money laundering late last year, are seeking a new trial.
Following crypto exchange FTX’s collapse, Bankman-Fried was found guilty on all seven counts, then sentenced to 25 years in prison and ordered to pay $11 billion in forfeiture. He has been serving his sentence in Brooklyn.
Bloomberg reports that Bankman-Fried’s appeal focuses on the behavior of US District Judge Lewis Kaplan, alleging that Kaplan’s rulings were “not just erroneous but unbalanced” and that the judge “continually ridiculed Bankman-Fried during trial, repeatedly criticized his demeanor, and signaled his disbelief of Bankman-Fried’s testimony.”
The appeal also claims that Kaplan “repeatedly mocked defense counsel” while helping the government make its case, and that he “improperly prodded” jurors to reach a quick verdict.
Bankman-Fried’s lawyers are seeking a new trial under a new judge. The U.S. attorney’s office that prosecuted the case said it does not plan to comment on the filing.
Keep reading the article on Tech Crunch
Telegram has had a tough few weeks lately. The messaging app’s founder, Pavel Durov, was arrested in late August and later released on a €5 million bail in France, charged with running a company complicit in distributing child sexual abuse material, and facilitating drug trafficking and organized fraud. Predictably, that crashed the price of the network’s cryptocurrency, Toncoin, by a third.
But last Wednesday, in the ritzy Dosan-daero part of Seoul, you could see no signs of gloom in the long line of people waiting to get into a party hosted by TON, the blockchain that runs on Telegram. Indeed, the crowd of developers, marketers, investors and other players from the blockchain ecosystem was in mood to celebrate: A few hours earlier, TON had announced at Korea Blockchain Week that transactions on the blockchain had crossed the 1 billion mark.
Unexpectedly, Durov’s high-profile arrest has proved to be something of a boon for Telegram. Downloads of the app spiked soon after the arrest, and it seems to have improved metrics on TON as well.
“Last week, TON hit all-time highs for active users and number of transactions during what, let’s be honest, is probably one of the worst weeks ever in news for TON,” Jack Booth, co-founder of TON Society, which manages the TON community, said during a conference at Korea Blockchain Week.
In theory, Durov’s status shouldn’t have a material impact on TON. Telegram and TON Foundation, which develops the blockchain, claim to be two independent entities. But things are more complicated in reality.
Durov started TON with his brother Nikolai Durov under Telegram, but the messaging app had to abandon the blockchain after the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission sued Telegram for conducting a massive unregistered initial coin offering. The app has since tried to distance itself from TON — at least by separating its corporate structure.
Meanwhile, a group of open-source developers and blockchain enthusiasts founded The Open Network Foundation, or TON Foundation, to continue developing the blockchain. Since then, TON has spawned several entities to support its fast-growing operations, including TON Society and The Open Platform, or TOP, which created the TON-based crypto wallet that runs on Telegram.
And to address concerns that the app’s disproportionate holding of Toncoin could compromise the decentralized nature of the network, Durov in February announced plans to “limit Telegram’s share of TON at ≈10% of the supply.”
Still, the fact that people panic-sold Toincoin speaks to the perception that TON and Telegram are closely related and somewhat interdependent. A person who identified himself as Minho told me at Korea Blockchain Week that he bought more TON since Durov’s arrest in the hopes that “prices will rebound following his release.”
Operationally, Telegram’s ambition of becoming a super-app like WeChat also depends heavily on the success of TON. To attract third-party developers, Telegram needs not only a proper tech stack, it requires a solid payments network to support in-app commerce, too. Only, instead of using a system that fiat system, it chooses cryptocurrency.
“When you’re tying your ecosystem to the success of the Telegram platform, then obviously when that comes into question, people start to doubt what could happen,” Booth told me. Still, he stressed that TON being a blockchain network gives it a level of independence that would let it survive without Telegram.
“At the end of the day, TON’s ecosystem is just using Telegram as a front-end experience. The app works on the website, too, so even in the most horrible event that Telegram is shut down, TON will still be available to run,” he said.
A billion transactions sounds like a big number, but how big is TON really? It’s tricky to compare on-chain activity, as decentralized networks are often tracked by different parties and measured by different metrics. But to give you a rough idea: Daily transactions on TON stood at 14.6 million on September 10 — that’s about 40% of the “non-vote” transactions on Solana, a more established blockchain that’s currently the fifth-largest by market cap. Toncoin, by market cap, stands at tenth place.
Nonetheless, the total value locked on TON is only $408 million, about 8% of Solana’s current worth of $4.77 billion, according to DefiLama.
These numbers are in line with Booth’s remarks that TON’s current boom is driven by a handful of viral “tap-to-earn” games that reward users with in-game assets for simply clicking on a button, and players trade these assets on exchanges where they are accepted. Solana, on the other hand, attracts far more capital thanks to its vibrant and much more varied decentralized finance (DeFi) ecosystem.
One such TON-based game called Hamster Kombat, where people roleplay as crypto exchange CEOs, has amassed 250 million monthly active users, according to Booth. That number is impressive, but it should be taken with a grain of salt, since the “tap-to-earn” mechanism used here is quite menial by modern video game standards and raises valid questions about such games’ longevity.
But for TON, and Telegram by extension, the value of clicker games lies in their ability to bring users to web3 with just a few taps (and keep them there with a financial incentive), Booth said during his speech. And it should be noted that playing web3 games requires users to jump many hoops in the first place — they have to download an app, set up a crypto wallet, and keep lengthy wallet passkeys safe — so anything that makes things easier is likely to be favored.
That’s not to say that studios aren’t trying to build more sophisticated titles for games for TON. Catizen lets players manage and optimize a colony of cats, and has attracted 30 million monthly users, over 2 million of whom are active on the blockchain, Tim Wong, chairman at Catizen Foundation, told TechCrunch. In less than six months, the game has racked up revenue of $21 million.
“Most web3 games acquire users without generating any in-game revenues,” Wong told me. “The mini-game ecosystem is already very established on WeChat, and it’s just starting on Telegram. We believe humans’ need for high-quality gameplay and their desire to spend on entertainment are universal.”
Toncoin may not be going to the moon anytime soon given the charges against Durov or how often Telegram is brought up in relation to bad news. But as is often the case with crypto projects, there is a good amount of fervor and optimism on display here. Roy Chen, a game dev from Denmark who has developed the console-inspired title HypeSaints that runs on TON, pointed out that the major impact of Durov’s arrest has been on Toincoin’s prices rather than the ecosystem itself.
“After all, the potential for crypto mass adoption through TON is huge, thanks to Telegram’s 950 million users,” he said.
Keep reading the article on Tech Crunch